usa-flag

为什么西方为巴黎游行而不为昆明游行?

2015-02-25 20:41 我要评论(0)

关键词:游行 昆明 巴黎

核心提示:自从法国讽刺报刊查理周刊的巴黎办事处遇袭并导致12人遇难以来,中国网民目睹西方的团结并且流出一定程度的不满

Expert answers range from the state of Chinese civil society to Western discrimination.  

By Bethany Allen-EbrahimianBethany

1111

In the days since the attacks that killed 12 people at the Paris offices of the satirical French newspaper Charlie Hebdo, Chinese netizens have watched the outpouring of solidarity and reacted with a degree of resentment. Why, some on Chinese social media have asked, does Paris get a unity march, when the knife attacks that killed 27 people in the Kunming railway station on March 1, 2014, received so little attention in the West? A panel of experts addresses this question.

自从法国讽刺报刊查理周刊的巴黎办事处遇袭并导致12人遇难以来,中国网民目睹西方的团结并且流出一定程度的不满。一些人在中国社交媒体上发出疑问:当2014年3月1日昆明火车站发生惨案导致27人死亡的时候为什么几乎没有获得西方的关注?上述专家为这个疑问做出了自己的解答。

Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian, Tea Leaf Nation Fellow, Foreign Policy magazine

《外国政策》杂志茶叶国家(媒体)研究员贝瑟尼·艾伦·艾布拉姆西

To answer the question most narrowly, there was no march after the Kunming knife attack because Chinese people in Kunming did not march.

111嗯

But the question is really a broader one: Why didn't Western countries demonstrate greater solidarity with China after the Kunming knife attack? Here, Chinese censorship and the so-called Great Firewall of censorship play an important role. French citizens share numerous social media platforms, notably Twitter, with millions of others worldwide. When a French artist created the hashtag #JeSuisCharlie and it started to trend on Twitter, people around the world were able to easily notice and join in the online solidarity. But by blocking Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube in mainland China, Chinese authorities have consciously and purposefully cut off Chinese Internet users from social media platforms widely used in the rest of the world. This makes it much more difficult for people outside of China to share in online solidarity with events close to the heart of Chinese netizens, as the Kunming attack clearly was.

但是更深的问题是:为什么西方国家在昆明持刀袭击事件后没有表明要与中国更加团结呢?原因是:中国的审查制度和所谓的审查防火长城扮演了重要的作用。法国公民与世界各地的无数人拥有很多共同的社交媒体阵地,尤其是推特。当法国艺术家创作出"我是查理"的微博时,它就在推特上推广了。但是由于在大陆屏蔽推特、非死不可和YouTube,中国当局有意识地并且有目的地切断中国网民与在其他地方广泛使用的社会媒体平台。这导致虽然昆明袭击发生了,但是外面的人很难通过互联网和中国网民站在一起。

In addition, the aura of authoritarian reach surrounding the reporting on the Kunming attack, as well as suppression of social media reactions, created initial skepticism among outside observers as to the true nature of what had transpired in Kunming. China's tightly controlled media were instructed to run only state-sanctioned reports, and avoid large headlines and gruesome photos. Witnesses to the knifing posted photos on Chinese social media, but censors quickly went through and deleted these photos and other non-sanctioned personal accounts of the brutal attack. Authorities immediately pinned the blame for the attack on "Xinjiang separatists" yet provided no evidence for this claim; as Western media outlets could not independently verify this, they were slow to adopt the language of terrorism. But Chinese netizens noticed this reluctance and slammed it as a Western "double standard." Some in China seem to remain unaware that Western media did later call the attack an act of terrorism, and resentment continues to simmer in Chinese social media — as the online reaction to the Paris march demonstrates.

另外,政府定的调子影响着昆明袭击的报道,同时也压制着社会媒体的反应。这导致了外部观察者最初对于昆明发生的事情持有怀疑态度。受中国严厉控制的媒体按照指示发布国家批准的报告,不用大标题和可怕的照片。目击者把相关照片上传到中国的社交媒体上,但是网监部门很快介入并且删除了这些照片还有其他未经过批准的对于此次残忍袭击的个人报道。当局立即谴责是"疆独"搞了这次袭击,然而却没有提供证据来表明自己的说法;由于西方媒体无法靠自己辨别这种说法,所以它们很难马上就采用这是恐怖袭击的说法。但是中国网民注意到了西方媒体表态的勉强,于是指责这是西方的"双重标准"。一些中国人似乎还不知道西方媒体的确在后来称这个事件是恐怖袭击,所以中国人的怨恨继续在网上发酵——从中国网民对巴黎游行所做出的反应可以看出这一点。

Taisu Zhang, Associate Professor, Duke University:

杜克大学 副教授 张太苏

As a Chinese citizen who observed both attacks and their social media aftermath from afar, I find it impossible to shake the impression that the Western reaction to Paris was indeed more visceral and passionate than the reaction to Kunming. It may be somewhat attractive to blame this on the relative paucity of information on Kunming, but it is also true that, even after the basic facts of the knife attacks were fairly well-established, they never triggered anything remotely close to the level of Western grief or outrage that immediately followed the Paris shootings. There is also a strong likelihood that, among the many millions of Facebook or Twitter users who reposted #JeSuisCharlie, only a minority had more than a cursory knowledge of the shootings, and only a tiny minority bothered to investigate their broader social or historical context. The Western online reaction to Paris was knee-jerk, emotional, and explosive — as it certainly should have been. The reaction to Kunming was, by and large, none of those things.

作为一个从宏观上观察过这两件袭击和各自媒体反响的中国人,我发现无法反驳的是,相对于昆明袭击,西方媒体对于巴黎的关心是更从心也更热烈的。这或许可以稍微怪罪于昆明袭击中相关信息的不足,但是另外一个事实是,即使在昆明刀袭的基本事实明确后,他们也从没有引发任何能稍微比得上巴黎枪击事件后立即形成的悲伤和愤怒。还有一个可能就是,在几百万非死不可或推特用户中,转发"我是查理"的人中也只有少部分对枪击事件有深入的了解,只有一小部分人深入调查这件事的社会历史背景。西方网络上对于巴黎事件的反应是下意识的,情绪化的和猛烈的——这当然是应该的。总的来说,对于昆明的反应根本就没有包含这些东西。

At the same time, there really is no reason to either expect or demand that Western audiences have a similar reaction to both incidents. I am among those who believe, reluctantly, that emotional discrimination against perceived "others" is human nature. For all the talk about globalization since the 1990s, it is probably no exaggeration to state that, to most Westerners, China remains a culturally inaccessible, ideologically foreign "other" that simply does not generate the kind of instinctive familiarity and sympathy that other Western societies do. Scholars have many concepts and theories to describe the intellectual and societal consequences of this "otherness" — orientalism, Eurocentrism, and so on — but it would be deeply misguided to believe this is a uniquely Western phenomenon (or, for that matter, a modern one; the in-group versus out-group mentality is as old as human history). As much as Chinese netizens might lash out against perceived Western apathy, they themselves did not necessarily flood Weibo with principled outrage or grief towards the Paris shootings. They might argue that this was simply a response to the Western reaction to Kunming, but that is an unsatisfying explanation either from an intellectual or moral standpoint. To claim that Western cultural and political imperialism, or the autocratic nature of the Chinese party-state, makes it difficult to emotionally respond to Paris or Kunming as one would to a similar incident within one's own cultural sphere is not so much a refutation of the "otherness" thesis, as it is an affirmation of it.

请支持独立网站,转载请注明本文链接:http://fm.m4.cn/2015-02/1264591.shtml

上一页 1 2 下一页 单页阅读

文章来源:龙腾网 | 责任编辑:瓶子

顶踩排行榜 打印本文

关键词:游行 昆明 巴黎

用户名: 快速登录 注册
array(16) { [0]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297333) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(60) "朱维群:达赖与暴力恐怖主义的关系能撇清吗" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297333.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451012368803.jpg" ["description"]=> string(259) "12月初,十四世达赖接受意大利媒体采访,称“仍有必要与IS对话,需要倾听、理解,给予所有的尊重”、“对要砍头的人如何倾听呢?只有用心来倾听敌人”。这番言论招致国际舆论的一致谴责。" ["time"]=> int(1451012400) } [1]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297348) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(67) "什么仇什么怨 西方为何对“妖魔化中国”情有独钟" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297348.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451028973285.jpg" ["description"]=> string(349) "由于很多圣诞礼物都写着made in china(中国制造),以至于70%西方小朋友认为圣诞老人是中国人。或许在西方孩子的眼中中国人的形象就是那个戴着红帽子,穿着红色的棉衣,脚穿红色靴子,有着白胡子的慈祥老爷爷,但是在西方大人的眼里中国人却是另一番样子。" ["time"]=> int(1451029018) } [2]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297347) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(57) "请善待我们救援者,哪怕我们只找到一只鸡" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297347.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451027495611.png" ["description"]=> string(260) "微博认证为蓝天救援队的外联部长@蓝天碎叫12月23日晚上发表了长博文《请善待我们救援者,哪怕我们只找到一只鸡》,文中那句“我在十米深的泥坑里凿着墙,你在敲着键盘骂我娘”让网友感叹。" ["time"]=> int(1451027559) } [3]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297341) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(45) "安轩平:打好意识形态斗争主动仗" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297341.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451020867548.jpg" ["description"]=> string(714) "中国纪检监察报点名批评某高校教授冯某以“真相”、“揭秘”为噱头,大肆宣扬历史教科书中的党史很多都不是“真实的历史”,捏造事实,歪曲党史军史,以混淆视听。这充分说明,当前意识形态领域的斗争复杂而尖锐,一些错误思潮暗流涌动,此起彼伏,竞相发声,大肆攻击中国特色社会主义、中国共产党的领导、社会主义核心价值观等,我们必须旗帜鲜明地把意识形态斗争作为事关党和国家生死存亡的大事来看,作为信仰之争、主义之争、制度之争的政治战来打,以共产党人的高度智慧和坚定意志,打好打赢意识形态主动仗。" ["time"]=> int(1451020875) } [4]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297325) ["icon"]=> string(5) "blank" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(66) "环球时报:香港极端反对派亟需搞清自己“是谁”" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297325.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451010268306.jpg" ["description"]=> string(273) "香港极端反对派给全国社会做了很低劣的“民主”示范,“港式民主”意味着政治对抗、社会动荡、人群撕裂以及经济发展被搅乱等等,包括一些稀奇古怪的现象会伴随出笼,这就是它给内地很多人的印象。" ["time"]=> int(1451010301) } [5]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297321) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(66) "李云飞阿訇:伊斯兰文明从制度上败给了西方文明" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297321.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451009743802.png" ["description"]=> string(192) "阿拉伯字母仍是仅次于拉丁字母的世界上使用最广泛的文字系统,伊斯兰文明也是当今人类社会唯一有可能把西方文明取而代之的世界文化体系。" ["time"]=> int(1451009766) } [6]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297292) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(81) "罗思义:中国在毛泽东治下取得了世界史上最伟大的社会成就" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297292.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451003936527.jpg" ["description"]=> string(210) "我们此前已经比较分析了中国1978年改革开放前后的经济增长情况。尽管如此,如果不了解1949年至1978年改革之前所取得巨大的社会成就,我们仍可能会被误导。" ["time"]=> int(1451003943) } [7]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297318) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(33) "香港特首进京也“跑部”" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297318.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451008702623.png" ["description"]=> string(179) "按照惯例,香港和澳门的特首每年在12月底时都会来北京向国家领导人汇报全年工作,也就是所谓的“述职”,再通俗点就是年终总结。" ["time"]=> int(1451008771) } [8]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297303) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(42) "虎牙妹:《万万没想到》有点渣" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297303.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451005863619.png" ["description"]=> string(228) "由于《万万》在网络剧时期累积了不小的人气,电影在点映时取得了相当大的成功,正当人们以为它能取得票房佳绩的时候,《万万》的风评却急转直下,在豆瓣上评分6.1。" ["time"]=> int(1451005740) } [9]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297295) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(72) "马平:作为前工程师,我认为深圳滑坡事故是这么回事" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297295.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451004166233.jpg" ["description"]=> string(183) "一般来说,规划和建设部门会分别对建设区附近的地质条件进行勘探,分析地质灾害的可能性。对于可能出现滑坡的地段,应该进行治理。" ["time"]=> int(1451004167) } [10]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297290) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(45) "寒竹:中国历史中的社会主义根基" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297290.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1225/1451003740374.jpg" ["description"]=> string(213) "在经济领域进一步深化市场化导向的改革,是当下中国发展的一个重要方向。市场能够最大限度地实现资源的有效配置,从而给经济发展提供强大而持续的动力。" ["time"]=> int(1451003764) } [11]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297248) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(69) "自导自演的和平演变:越南反共总理政治炒作的背后" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297248.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1224/1450949829631.png" ["description"]=> string(303) "越南中央级的党报党刊、军报军刊最近发表大量文章,阐述党的路线和大政方针,同时揭露、批判“国内外各种敌对势力和政治机会主义分子”在十二大前的各种破坏阴谋和伎俩,强调要防范和反对“和平演变”和“颜色革命”。" ["time"]=> int(1450949950) } [12]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297247) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(42) "津巴布韦缘何“相中”人民币?" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297247.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1224/1450948423306.png" ["description"]=> string(140) "中国是津巴布韦的第二大贸易合作伙伴,每年双边贸易额超过10亿元,津巴布韦对人民币的需求日趋强烈。" ["time"]=> int(1450948518) } [13]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297246) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(33) "台湾选举提前结束了吗?" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297246.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1224/1450946885538.jpg" ["description"]=> string(108) "本来选战就是中间选民的争夺战,这一次,国民党要找回自己的基本盘,怎么了?" ["time"]=> int(1450946760) } [14]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297058) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(90) "清华博士:台湾是“杀出来的奴才,打出来的顺民,惯出来的孽种”" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297058.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1223/1450833056693.png" ["description"]=> string(297) "一直以来,中国政府奉行对台让利政策,对台湾的开放程度远远超过台湾对大陆的开放程度,就已在太阳花运动中被否定的“贸服协定”为例,对大陆的要求几乎全部是高于WTO中的规定,而对台湾却几乎全部是低于WTO的规定。" ["time"]=> int(1450833467) } [15]=> array(11) { ["contentid"]=> int(1297067) ["icon"]=> string(0) "" ["iconsrc"]=> string(0) "" ["title"]=> string(60) "金庸:揭中国人不擅长打仗为何却能赢的真相" ["color"]=> string(0) "" ["url"]=> string(46) "http://www.m4.cn/opinion/2015-12/1297067.shtml" ["subtitle"]=> string(0) "" ["suburl"]=> string(0) "" ["thumb"]=> string(47) "http://upload.m4.cn/2015/1223/1450834511242.jpg" ["description"]=> string(243) "现在许多西方学者都认为,地球就这样大了,无止境地追求、扩充,是不可能的,也是不可取的。今後只能接受中国的哲学,要平衡、要和谐,民族与民族之间要相互协作,避免战争。" ["time"]=> int(1450834575) } }

朱维群:达赖与暴力恐怖主义的关系能撇清吗

1占豪丨中国改变世界的大招正在起关键作用!
2常规武器中的顶尖之作:体积爆炸物(ОДБ
3美国四胞胎妈妈秀400万美元帐单 网友震惊
4卞海涛丨菲律宾侵占仁爱礁的图谋不会得逞
5国防部:坚决反对美凭空制造敌人的危险做法
6细数美军工复合体如何获取“战争暴利”
7国防部:只要不搞“台独”,就没必要焦虑
8牛弹琴丨这件事,特朗普真做不到
9后沙:《杜鹃花落》,文责自负!
10胡懋仁|西方大公司放弃电动汽车意味着什么
11中方强烈不满,已向韩方交涉
12邱国正之子被爆涉黄 台安全部门已立案调查
13以色列士兵肆意打砸加沙商店取乐
14以色列北部遭火箭弹袭击 1人死亡
15俄军又击毁一辆美制"阿布拉姆斯"坦克
16巴勒斯坦武装派别巷战伏击以军装甲车
17安理会强烈谴责巴基斯坦恐怖袭击事件
18无视停火决议巴以冲突仍在继续
19欧洲委员会为科索沃加入开绿灯 武契奇称将
20俄罗斯被捕贪官涉及重大司法案件
1江平舟|莫斯科恐袭 美国事先就知情?
2胡懋仁|西方资产阶级带来的观念害人不浅
3突发!俄军发动“最大规模”夜袭
4占豪丨"巴恐"瞄准中国下黑手 不能容忍!
5俄自媒体揭露:全球恐怖势力竟源自单一团伙
6马斯克:美国需要一股"红色浪潮",否则就完
7深得法国精髓:民众在美高官住宅前倾倒粪便
8乌国安国防秘书长侮辱中国特别代表被解雇
9索纳丽丨你美国人买不起电动汽车,这就是原
10占豪丨中国改变世界的大招正在起关键作用!
11扎哈罗娃评联合国立场:是谴责不是感到悲痛
12重大突破!中国完成首列氢能源列车运行试验
13牛弹琴|跨国谋杀案还真是印度特工干的!
14"中国速度太快"!德国总理朔尔茨"羡慕了"
15天都新闻丨莫斯科恐袭五个关键信息值得关注
16陈金龙|试论毛泽东的历史自信
17中国留俄学生:我现在做的只能是来献血
18美国学者:基辅精英人士明白乌克兰已经输了
19中国国防部:驱离菲运送物资的船只合理合法
20英国专家:俄对乌发起了技术最精巧的打击
1夜央 占豪|央视“国骂”令万千网友“破防
2罗思义|美国耗费巨资试图说服中国内部各种
3许多人曾崇拜西方价值观,但现在幻想破灭…
4胡懋仁|兰德公司的两份报告
5戴旭丨很多国人不知反毛背后的大阴谋,令人
6张文木 | 政治的膨胀与政治的文本——历史
7美军公布:六代机最新进展……
8江平舟|莫斯科恐袭 美国事先就知情?
9李瑞昌|对毛主席最好的纪念是什么?
10牧心 占豪|中美同时拒签 这一默契将引发重
11金灿荣|大陆海警重拳反击 台湾问题快要解
12司马南|美国为什么怕中国汽车?
13科罗廖夫|温压弹能让敌人缺氧而死 谣传!
14牛弹琴|这两个最新动向,让人瞠目结舌
15张文木丨德国宣战后 苏军上报斯大林的报告
16乔新生|特里芬难题决定了美国经济不可能软
17统一"绊脚石"正被踢开!蔡英文最怕一幕发生
18申鹏|这岛上,又岂止“三害”?
19远航|台独是美国豢养的一条狗
20亨利·曼斯|美国面临的危险程度远超俄罗斯